clearly Gwindor. the man had his whole life demolished and didn’t even get poetic resolution about it. he was slowly broken apart and left behind so that the narrator could tell the story of someone much cooler’s much more beautiful suffering. I think that’s much more interesting
You know who's an under-appreciated Bad Elf Dad? Fingolfin. When you despair of being able to lead your people to victory and go on a deliberate suicide mission and leave your kid holding the bag for the downfall of the kingdom, you get on the Shitty Dad List. He ain't the worst, but he's earned a spot, unlike some characters listed.









